Bankruptcy on taxes

Bankruptcy will only discharge income taxes.

It does not work on sales taxes, or employee withholding taxes.

Discharge of taxes works the same way in both Chapter 7 bankruptcy and Chapter 13 bankruptcy.

Discharge of taxes is a complicated and technical subject, and you should not rely on this article as legal advice on whether or not your taxes would be discharged by a bankruptcy.

The only way to be sure that your taxes will be discharged in a bankruptcy is to talk with an attorney who will check into the circumstances surrounding your tax debts.

WHEN DO TAXES GET DISCHARGED?

In order for income taxes to be discharged in bankruptcy, you must meet several requirements.

Most of these requirements are related to how long it has been since the taxes were due, and how long from when the return was filed.

You must satisfy each one of the 5 rules for your taxes to be dischargeable.

I have listed the 5 rules below:

1. The 3-year rule

Income taxes are not dischargeable until at least 3 years have passed since the tax return was last due.

For example:

2012 tax returns were due on April 15, 2013
3 years from April 15, 2013 is April 15, 2016

So 2012 income taxes can first become dischargeable on April 15, 2016.

This is a long wait, but if you owe taxes from several years ago, then a bankruptcy might be the best way to handle them.*

2. The 2-year rule

The tax return must have been actually filed at least 2 years before the filing of the bankruptcy case, and this rule is more complicated than it sounds.

This is because it:

Includes any extensions to file the tax return
Can include amendments to your tax returns

In some jurisdictions, this rule is never satisfied if the IRS or state taxing authority (Minnesota Department of Revenue in my jurisdiction) filed the return for you.

When the taxing authority files the return, it is called a service-filed return and can make the taxes nondischargeable in bankruptcy forever*

3. The 240-day rule

The tax amount must also be assessed at least 240 days before the filing of the bankruptcy petition.

What is an assessment?

For the IRS, at least, assessment happens when the amount is notated in the Secretary of the Treasury’s records.

For state taxes, it happens when the tax liability is final. This does not happen immediately when you file the tax return in question.

It usually, however, happens before the 2-year or 3-year rule has finished.

The 240-day rule can be a problem for assessments of certain new taxes or penalties.*

4. The non-fraudulent return rule

This rule explains itself better than the others.

If you prepared the return fraudulently, then the taxes from that year are not dischargeable in bankruptcy.

The question of what is a badly prepared tax return and what is a fraudulently prepared tax return depends on very specific facts, and is beyond the scope of this article.

5. The no-willful-attempt-to-evade rule

This rule says that a tax debt is not dischargeable if the taxpayer made a willful attempt to evade paying the taxes.

Courts have been all over the place on what they decide is a willful attempt to evade.

Some courts have found that depositing one’s paycheck in a girlfriend’s account so that the IRS couldn’t levy it was a willful attempt to evade
Others have found that failing to report over $200,000 of income in an offshore account was not

Like rule number 4, this article cannot completely explain the subject which is why it is best to talk with an experienced Minnesota bankruptcy attorney about whether or not this might be a problem for you.

Remember, all communication with attorneys and their staffs are privileged.

*There are events that can pause these time periods. For example, the clock on the 3-year rule stops for every day that you are in an active Chapter 13 bankruptcy. There are several other such rules, which make taxes in bankruptcy a very complicated subject.

WHAT HAPPENS IF THE TAXES DON’T GET DISCHARGED?

If your taxes are not dischargeable in bankruptcy, then it is best to work out a payment plan with the IRS.

The IRS has very detailed financial rules for what they require as a payment, but the final payment is usually affordable.

You could:

Try an offer in compromise which is another tax resolution procedure where you pay the IRS what you can afford, and they forgive the rest
Decide to simply wait until you do qualify to discharge the taxes in bankruptcy
File a Chapter 13 Bankruptcy and use the monthly payments to pay off any nondischargeable tax debts over 5 years, and your other debts will be discharged at the same time

Chapter 13 Bankruptcy is useful because the bankruptcy protects you from any act to collect a debt for the 5 years while you make the payments. It even protects you against acts from the IRS or state taxing authority to collect debts.

WHAT TO DO NEXT

If you want more information about bankruptcy and taxes, and whether filing Chapter 13 Bankruptcy in Minnesota is right for you, then why not not speak to us now at 612.824.4357?

We’ll give you all the help and advice you need.

Alternatively, fill out our free Bankruptcy Evaluation Form to see if filing for Chapter 7 Bankruptcy or Chapter 13 Bankruptcy in Minnesota is right for you.

We’re looking forward to helping you.